Millions on line in fight over Kaw Lake Pipeline
ByAlexanderEwald
CNHI News Oklahoma
Enid, Okla. - The city could be on the hook to pay millions for one of the final pieces of the Kaw Lake water pipeline puzzle.
By next summer, the city of Enid could go to a jury trial in order to settle an eminent domain dispute for the first time, officials said, rather than pay a Garfield County landowner $2.755 million recently awarded as just compensation for his property.
The award would be the largest the city’s ever had to pay to acquire a condemned property under eminent domain.
However, city officials disagree with the amount, which is almost entirely made up of costs from a lease terminated during the city’s lawsuit that court-appointed commissioners determined last June.
“We don’t think that award’s correct,” City Manager Jerald Gilbert said Thursday, so the city intends to go to mediation with the property owner over the amount if that attempt fails, then go to jury trial.
In order to build a 50-foot stretch located around the middle of the planned 70-mile-long raw water pipeline, attorneys for the city have been attempting to invoke eminent domain to acquire a perpetual land easement and a temporary easement northeast of Garber. Landowner Robert Anderson, an Enid resident, had refused to grant the city right of way to his 120-acre property, so the city filed a petition to condemn the property in district court a year ago.
Anderson’s son, former state Sen. Patrick Anderson, who has been representing him in court, said the city has repeatedly ignored his father’s requests to find an alternate path for the pipeline segment.
“Instead, the city of Enid chose to be a bully and force its way across my father’s property through the process of eminent domain,” Anderson said.
The city’ legal actions during the condemnation lawsuit resulted in an award amount much higher than original offers, according to both the Andersons and June’s final report from condemnation commissioners.
R obert Anderson had initially been offered $4,800 for the parcel located on his 160 acres, but this amount ballooned to $2.755 million after a solar farm company already leasing Anderson’s property for future construction canceled its agreement, rather than also be sued in condemnation.
In May 2019 - a month after Anderson entered his lease agreement he was sent a letter by Gilbert offering him $4,782.55 for the easements, rounded up to $4,800. The city’s land services agent Steve Smith then contacted Anderson two months later with the easement request, again offering $120 per rod for 39.85 rods.
Located northeast of Garber, the proposed pipeline path would come within 100 feet of the intersection of Lake Hellums Road and Sinclair Road, then zig-zag across Anderson’s property - going across a creek, through a thicket of trees and up a hill of reportedly “highly erodible” soil, according to a filing from Patrick Anderson.
Robert Anderson reportedly told the city his confidential lease agreement was based on no pipelines running under the property. Because of this, he asked the city to instead go around his property with the Kaw Lake pipeline.
Anderson also stated that the solar panel farm lease was expected to increase the value of the land due to renewable energy policies of the then-incoming Biden administration.
Over a year passed with no further contact from the city, but in June 2020, the Enid City Commission approved an emergency resolution for the city’s legal team to move forward with the condemnation.
In November and December 2020, Tulsa-based attorney Danny Williams filed three condemnation petitions on behalf of the city in Garfield County District Court, with one naming Anderson as a defendant.
Under Oklahoma state statute, a public entity such as a city government can petition to take private property for a specific public use such as a construction project. In return, the public entity will provide a property owner with “just compensation” - the value of the property, as well as any injury to property not taken - determined by a group of three independent, court-appointed commissioners.
A protective order was to be put in place when the case was put on District Judge Tom Newby’s docket. However, Williams obtained the name of the lessee, Innovative Solar 180, and decided to also sue the company in an amended petition on Feb. 3, 2021.
Patrick Anderson said his father provided the city with a copy of the 20-year solar farm lease.
Williams also mailed a new summons to Innovative Solar 180, which was returned March 8. Nearly three weeks later, the parent company Innovative Solar Systems responded that it had terminated its lease with Anderson and requested removal as a defendant, with agreement from the city.
According to the commissioners’ report, this terminated 20-year lease with Innovative Solar Systems cost Anderson an estimated $2.755 million.
After months of delays because of the amended petition, commissioners Tom Andrew, Dennis Skaggs and Kyle Clark determined the city should pay Anderson this much to compensate him for both his property and for the amount of money Anderson has lost from the lease agreement.
Coming to $2,755,200 total, these amounts were specifically set out under the terms of the lease agreement, Patrick Anderson said.
Commissioners then recommended the city alternatively continue down parcels of other acquired land to the north and cross the section to the west of Anderson’s land, where the city also entered into easement agreements with Anderson’s neighbors.
“While that might cost more in construction, it surely will not approach the $2,755,200.00 lost to Mr. Anderson from crossing his property,” the report reads.
Patrick Anderson also asserts that an alternate route for the pipeline “clearly exists” so the line can bypass the property.
Budgeted at roughly $317 million total, the Kaw Lake Water Supply program is the largest project in the city of Enid’s history.
Gilbert said plans to build the pipeline and the various treatment plants from Osage County to Enid have been in the works since the late-’00s, during which longterm studies were held even before the massive droughts in Northwest Oklahoma early in the next decade. Further studies determined Kaw Lake was a feasible, longterm source of water for the city, Gilbert said.
The pipeline is set to provide Enid residents with an average 10.5 million gallons of water a day once it’s complete.

Water is released from the Kaw Lake Dam. (CNHI Photo)