SHARE Share Button Share Button SHARE

Is a special session on mandates really needed?

District 27 Senator Casey Murdock wants the Oklahoma legislature to hold another special session this year and says he just needs a few more lawmakers to sign on to make it happen. The session will try to deal with federal COVID-19 vaccination mandates.

That’s fine, but the question is what will a special session really accomplish.

The mandate ordering companies with over 100 employees is already being challenged in court, though apparently Oklahoma hasn’t joined in yet, and the Occupational Safety and Health Administration has already suspended enforcement while the issue is in the courts.

This, we would think, should include a rule reportedly issued by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services requiring vaccinations for providers participating in the federal programs.

Exactly how will a state law force changes to that rule? Medicare is a federal program. Medicaid may be administered by states but receives federal funding. A state law isn’t likely to hold up. So what will a special session do? Make legislators feel like they are doing something? Do lawmakers really want to spend a week or more in December fighting a federal mandate they probably can’t overturn.

The legality of a federal mandate affecting private business is something the courts need to hear and rule on before any legislative action should occur and any ruling in federal court will likely cover the entire country.

We expect the issue to be in the courts for a good while. The proposal by Sen. Murdock can be brought up just as easily in the regular session early next your, sparing the expense of another special session.

SHARE Share Button Share Button SHARE